On Monday, The Hindu reported how critical conditions for anti-corruption penalties and an escrow account for payments were dropped days before the Rafale deal was signed.
 
Before that, it had reported on defence ministry objections to “parallel negotiations” conducted by the Prime Minister’s Office.
 
The latest report cites the dissent note signed off by three domain experts on the Indian team – MP Singh, Adviser (Cost), a Joint Secretary-level officer from the Indian Cost Accounts Service; AR Sule, Financial Manager (Air); and Rajeev Verma, Joint Secretary and Acquisitions Manager (Air).
 
The eight-page note was written more than a month after the team’s negotiations with the French side were completed and three months before the inter-governmental agreement was signed, on September 23, 2016. The deal had been announced by PM Modi during a visit to France in 2015.
 
“Commenting on the final Euro 7.87 billion cost of the new Rafale deal, the domain experts stated that ‘the reasonability of price offered by the French Government is not established.
 
Even the final price offered by the French Government cannot be considered as ‘better terms’ compared to the MMRCA [medium multi-role combat aircraft] offer and therefore not meeting the requirement of the Joint Statement’,” the report said.
 
According to the experts, the final price offered by the French government was 55.6 per cent above the benchmark decided in advance and “5.3 per cent higher than the Aligned Cost of the commercial quotes” in the Congress-era deal.
 
They also noted that Eurofighter Typhoon fighter jet, which too had qualified for the contract, would have turned out to be much cheaper.
 
“They also concluded that the delivery schedule of even the first 18 of the 36 flyaway Rafale aircraft in the new deal was slower than the one offered for the 18 flyaway aircraft in the original procurement process,” The Hindu added.
 
While the Congress era deal had set a ceiling of 48 months to deliver the first 18 jets, the new agreement set the ceiling at 53 months, the experts said.
 
Congress chief Rahul Gandhi was quick to highlight the new report, saying that it had “demolished” the government’s arguments, conveyed both to parliament and the Supreme Court.
 
The Congress leader has doggedly accused the government of signing an overpriced deal for 36 Rafale fighter jets at an inflated price to benefit Anil Ambani, whose rookie defence firm was recommended as an offset partner for Dassault, the company manufacturing the aircraft.
 
But both Anil Ambani, Dassault and the government have denied the allegation